Which commander made the best decision at the Battle of Gettysburg? Who turned in the worst performance? Is the movie Gettysburg any good? We asked a panel of Gettysburg experts—from historians to licensed battlefield guides—these and other questions relating to the history and memory of the epic engagement in July 1863 between George G. Meade’s Army of the Potomac and Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia. Below are their answers.
Library of Congress (Howard, Sickles, Hill); National Portrait Gallery (Hancock)(From left) Major General Oliver Otis, Winfield Scott Hancock, Major General Daniel Sickles, and A.P. Hill.
Best Command Decision
Major General Oliver Otis Howard’s decision to establish a fallback defensive position at Cemetery Hill on July 1 (24%)
Best Command Performance
Winfield Scott Hancock (33%)
“No other officer had as positive an effect on every day of the battle.”
—Ethan S. Rafuse
Worst Command Decision
Major General Daniel Sickles’ movement of his III Corps from its assigned position at Cemetery Ridge to the Peach Orchard on July 2 (36%)
Worst Command Performance
A.P. Hill (28%)
“He strikes out every day of the battle, but especially on July 2, when the entire momentum of the Confederate assault fell apart on his front.”
—Jessie Wheedleton
Maine State Archives (Chamberlain); Library of Congress (Greene)Colonel Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain (left) and Brigadier General George Sears Greene
Overrated Command Performances
Union
Colonel Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain’s defense of Little Round Top (58%)
“Yes, he did the right thing at the right moment, but it was also irrelevant to the outcome of the battle.” —Allen C. Guelzo
Confederate
General James Longstreet’s leadership of the Army of Northern Virginia’s First Corps (25%)
“Longstreet should be judged above all as a problematic leader and unenthusiastic subordinate at Gettysburg.” —Christopher S. Stowe
Underrated Command Performances
Union
Brigadier General George Sears Greene’s fortification and defense of Culp’s Hill (25%)
“Greene managed to hold the Union’s far right flank despite being wildly outnumbered, and engaged in the most protracted period of continuous fighting during the entire battle.” —James J. Broomall
Confederate
General Richard Ewell’s actions on July 1 (14%)
“Not a great general by any measure, but Ewell never gets credit for the success his corps had on the battle’s opening day.” —D. Scott Hartwig
Debrief Gettysburg officers
Maine State Archives (Chamberlain); Library of Congress (Stuart, Lee, Longstreet, Meade, Buford).
Do you give the movie Gettysburg (1993) a thumbs up or down?
Best Gettysburg movie performance
Sam Elliott as John Buford (45%)
Runner-Up: Jeff Daniels as Joshua Chamberlain (23%)
IMDBSam Elliott from the movie Gettysburg
Best Battle of Gettysburg novel
Michael Shaara, The Killer Angels (1974) (83%)
Best history of the Battle of Gettysburg
Edwin B. Coddington, Gettysburg: A Study in Command (1968) (36%)
Runner-up: Stephen W. Sears, Gettysburg (2003) (23%)
Panelists
Andrew S. Bledsoe; Patrick Brennan; James J. Broomall; Judkin Browning; Eric A. Campbell; Richard P. Condon; Mark H. Dunkelman; Codie Eash; Zachery Fry; Gary W. Gallagher; Lesley J. Gordon; Allen C. Guelzo; D. Scott Hartwig; John S. Heiser; Brian Matthew Jordan; Christian B. Keller; Larry Korczyk; Ashley Whitehead Luskey; Jennifer M. Murray; Ethan S. Rafuse; Brooks D. Simpson; Adam I.P. Smith; Christopher S. Stowe; Jessie Wheedleton; and Cecily Zander.



